Month: July 2018

Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed’s first 100 days

This article describes the stellar accomplishments made in the past 100 days since the swearing-in of Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed.

1. Fostered Internal Stability

Today marks the 100th day of the premiership of Dr Abiy Ahmed. His performance so far can only be rated as outstanding on all fronts. The popularity of the numerous measures he has taken so far and the speed with which each of them is delivered are nothing short of a miracle. The PM has done in this short period what many wouldn’t even imagine getting done in years. His name has now become synonymous with optimism for an overwhelming majority of Ethiopians. International News Outlets such as the BBC have described him as “one of the most dynamic and charismatic politicians to emerge in modern Africa.”

Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed came to power right in the middle of the worst political and social crisis that hit the country in decades. Due to popular unrest hitting major regions in Ethiopia, the government was forced to declare martial law twice in two years’ time since 2016. Demonstrations, roadblocks and conflicts flared up in almost all major urban and rural areas. Violence reached the outskirts of the capital, Addis Ababa, a city of at least 5 million, severely limiting day-to-day public affairs. Despite EPRDF’s desperate attempt to curb unrest, the unrest finally culminated in the resignation of its chairperson and the election of PM Abiy Ahmed through a tightly contested inter-party election.

1.1 Inspired the Nation

Even before coming to the helm of the country’s political power, Abiy Ahmed was known for his charisma. He was frequently quoted saying “Kal yigedlal, Kal yadinal” which roughly translates to “A word can kill, a word can save”. He thoroughly acted on this belief in his first 100 days, starting with his inauguration speech at the parliament. His inspirational quotes were carried far and wide throughout the nation. His words have become ubiquitous adorning window panes and bumper stickers all over Ethiopia. His message of unity through diversity and revival of the “Ethiopiawinet” (Ethiopianism) is widely celebrated, and his notion of “medemer” (synergy) has become a colloquial word. His frank and transparent manners, the way in which he spoke of his mother, wife and all women at his swearing-in ceremony not only stole the hearts of many but also gave away signs of the seriousness of the change that is taking place in Ethiopia. The phrases he used such as “When alive, we are Ethiopians, and in death, we become the land that is Ethiopia” are favourites among patriotic Ethiopians who are longing for a message of unity and solidarity in the midst of ethnic rivalry apparent for the past several years.

1.2 First-hand discussion with the people

PM Abiy Ahmed made stabilising the troubled nation his primary objective. He made regional visits and discussed with the community on matters that are important to them. He also delivered messages of solidarity in languages, customs and attires akin to the specific regions, raising issues that were taboo in Ethiopian politics yet very reflective of the local need. He kicked off his visit with the most affected areas in the last three years of anti-government demonstrations such as Ambo, Bale, Dembi-dollo and Gondar and continued to other regions such as Tigray, Hawassa, and Afar to experience first-hand the state of affairs in the different regions to ensure all voices are heard. His message of peace and unity was delivered in such an out-of-the-box and disarming way that it brought about a tangible impact on the nations and nationalities embraced in the country.

1.3 Expanded Political Space

Despite efforts exerted to widen the ever-narrowing post-2005 political space by the leading party EPRDF; the first tangible steps were actually undertaken in the last 100 days. This was evident with the release and pardon of political leaders. He lifted bans on political parties, website and various media outlets that were deemed terrorists and affiliates. and even invited them to operate locally. These ground-breaking changes helped in convincing the opposition and the sizeable Ethiopian diaspora that the change was not cosmetic but genuine and is bringing many onboard to participate in the country’s affairs. Furthermore, a draft pardon proclamation has been submitted to parliament for approval that will streamline the way the government releases wrongly accused and imprisoned individuals and organizations. Previous anti-terrorism, cyber-terrorism and other sweeping proclamations are put under revision by the newly appointed attorney general to pave the way for a less intrusive government and greater democratic reform.

The Prime Minister’s bold defense of his reforms in front of the House of People’s representatives went as far as blaming some within the government itself for terrorising the Ethiopian people, and firing and reshuffling of a series of untouchable civil servants. He is laying out a clear policy direction towards good-governance and accountability. Consequently, even state-owned/affiliated media such as EBC/ETC/Fana started broadcasting various rights abuses including in the criminal justice system. Such investigative reporting by the press is paving the way for those in the security and prison systems to be held accountable and brought to justice.

Another proof of the new administration’s move to widen the democratic space is the virtually nation-wide rallies organised by the local communities themselves in support of the new pro-democracy reforms. Demonstrators carried banners and flags of their choice while reflecting varied political views. However, all the demonstration were markedly peaceful and pro-reform except for an attack that killed few people and wounded many.

1.4 Reformed the Security Sector

Police, the military, the internal security, correctional facilities and other within the military-security establishment within the country were the ones that suffered from a serious lack of public confidence. Reforming these institutions in a top-down approach was a vital step towards restoring public trust and stability. It was along these lines that Dr Abiy Ahmed started by replacing old-guard veterans within these institutes in rapid succession. This was done in a respectful manner to ensure continuity in accordance with state protocol and full-honour retirement to the likes of the head of defence, head of security and former prime minister.

2. Fostered Diplomacy and Foreign Relations

Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed has markedly departed from the usual trend of conducting diplomacy within the horn and Africa. His “win-win” approach towards neighboring diplomacy, while rejecting the previous decades’ old trend of the typical “us-versus-them” and “allies vs. enemies” seems to work. In that regard, his biggest wins include putting an end to the “no peace – no war” situation with Eritrea that persisted for decades, improving regional economic ties and cooperation which has now created a huge movement for his nomination for the upcoming Nobel Peace Prize.

2.1 Improved Ethio-Eritrea Relations

20 years ago, the relations between the two countries deteriorated culminating in one of Africa’s bloodiest war. Since then “no war-no peace” stance between the two countries costed human lives and damaged both economies. Previously Eritrea maintained there would be no negotiations until Ethiopian troops pulled out of Eritrean as per the decision of the international boundary commission. However, this black curtain between the two countries has been shred and overtures have been made as evident with the recent visit of high-level delegates from Eritrea and the return visit to Asmara, Eritrea by the Prime Minister of Ethiopia. The parade throughout the 45km drive from the Airport to Asmara Palace showered the Ethiopian delegates with unprecedented public support and love.

2.2 Prioritized Security in the Horn of Africa

Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed travelled to all the neighbouring countries in past three months and met with South Sudan’s President and opposition leaders in Addis Ababa. As they say in political science, “Every country has the right to choose their allies. However, no one can choose their neighbours”. With this logic in mind, the Prime Minister has given priority in deepening diplomatic relations with neighbouring countries in the horn of Africa.

2.3 Signed New Agreements

Despite the fact that the Ethiopian government has been working towards the adoption of a principle of giving and taking an approach with its neighbours, the negotiations over the past 100 days were far-reaching. A deal was made to develop and operate a shipping port in Djibouti and Ethiopia to extend stakes to Djibouti in the telecom and other mutually agreed infrastructures. These measures benefit Ethiopia from an economic and political standpoint in the long run.

2.4 Took a stand on the Red-Sea Geopolitics

Following the Yemeni civil war, several Arab nations and Iran have been supporting either the ruling government or the rebels. Iran, Qatar, Turkey and Sudan are supporting one team whereas, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Egypt are on the other, making the Horn of Africa a volatile region. These groups have set up some military camps and bases including in Eritrea. Ethiopia did not choose sides for the past years. While this may deem beneficial, the repercussion of not choosing side could be hazardous. Over the last three months, a number of measures have been taken to take a stance. In particular, the visits to Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates have created an enabling environment for further discussions with Egypt and Eritrea. In addition to the economic burden of the effects of the effects of maritime travel, and the gateway in this area, the internet security of this gateway is immense. Furthermore, if Egypt had succeeded in placing its maritime force in Eritrea, it would have been a significant implication for the sovereignty of Ethiopia. The breakthroughs in the last 100 days to minimise such risks are the closure of the port deal with Eritrea could be beneficial in the long term.

3. Took measures to improve the Economy

Although the economy has been growing for the past ten years, over the past three years, the absence of internal stability and the long-stalled government mega projects were daunting challenges. Furthermore, infrastructure projects demand foreign currency and export capacity did not increase as expected which resulted in a large discrepancy whereby the foreign currency exchange was overcrowded by black market smugglers. As a result of this economic shortfall, jobs have plummeted, especially in the construction sector and the cost of living has increased significantly exacerbated by the increase in unemployed youth. Different activities have been accomplished over the last 100 days to temporarily mitigate these and other economic problems such as by bringing in over 3 Billion Dollars from the United Arab Emirates.

3.1 Engaged with the Private Sector 

Under the premise that the engagement of the private sector is important in the economic reforms that the Prime Minister is aiming for, he has also carried out discussion with the business community at the Sheraton Hotel and the presidential palace on multiple various occasions. The investors inquired clarifications, and the Prime Minister highlighted the roles and responsibilities of the private sector and government to contribute towards the sustainable development of the country.

3.2 Solving Forex Crisis

One of the top issues discussed with the private sector was how to address the shortage of foreign currency. Several short-term measures have been taken to address this shortcoming. The 3 Billion Dollar donation from the United Arab Emirates has also been cited as an example, and the reform in the overall setup of the National Bank of Ethiopia should bring about a lasting change.

3.3 Encouraged Privatization

The Prime Minister announced a program to liberalise the economy and partially or fully privatise state-run firms. This may include selling of shares to foreign investors in large state companies such as Ethiopian Airlines with the intent to bring in hard currency to allow payments on outstanding debts and ease import bottlenecks.

3.4 Took serious measures about Good Governance

Evaluation of planning and implementation of the public sector in many government offices has not been transparent. This problem is evident also at ministerial levels. Prime Minister Abiy mentioned that in addition to the House of People’s Representatives’evaluation, another review would be made open to the general public in the coming fiscal year. Moreover, these government offices will have their plans published on their websites at the beginning of the fiscal year further inculcating transparency and accountability.

3.5 National Budget approved by the House of People’s Representatives

Following the 2010 financial year, the Council of Ministers has approved a budget of 346 billion (915 million 451 thousand 948 birrs) for the year 2011 E.C. (2018/2019 fiscal year). The budget was approved by the House of Peoples’ Representatives. Out of the allocated budget, regular expenditures totalled 91,067,160,000 birrs. The prime minister answered and clarified questions from members of the House during the annual budget presentation which was aired live on national TV. This budget allocation was different in that this administration made its budget with particular emphasis on poverty reduction, attention on not printing money to cover the budget deficit. Promises from donors and external sources have not been included but rather improve tax collection capacity of the government. The 2011E.C. budget was different in that it realised the level of debt burden Ethiopia is experiencing and intended to lower it.

4. Fostered Social Cohesion

4.1. Prime Minister Abiy attended various events and took the opportunity to speak to thousands of youth about “love and forgiveness.” The manner it was delivered was unlike any EPRDF leadership regarding content and delivery and captured the hearts and minds of the Ethiopian youth to actively participate in political and social affairs in the country.

4.2. The prime minister has initiated the effort to reconcile the differences between the Ethiopian Islamic Affairs Council and Committee for the Solution of Ethiopian Muslim Affairs. This has been recognised as a major step as the country has embarked on a peaceful, loving, and co-operative journey. Also, the prime minister has also initiated the reconciliation process between the Ethiopian Orthodox Church community at home and abroad.

4.3. Abiy Ahmed in his fourth trip official trip abroad to Saudi Arabia took his entourage to visit Mohammed, the Ethiopian boy who was in a coma for the past twelve years due to medical error and assured his mom and the community they will soon get justice. He also discussed the release and return of Ethiopian prisoners to their country.

4.4. Prime Minister Abiy is known to comfort patients in various hospitals and participate in blood donations drive.

Re-opening roads to Eritrea’s Red Sea ports is a priority for Ethiopia

Ethiopia wants to make the re-opening of two roads connecting it to two of Eritrea’s Red Sea ports a priority in the two nations’ reconciliation process, a government spokesman said on Wednesday 11 July.

In a move that ended a 20-year military stand-off, the Horn of African neighbours agreed on Monday to open embassies, develop ports and resume flights.

The historic reconciliation could transform politics and security in the volatile Horn region, which lies along one of the world’s busiest shipping routes.

Ethiopian government spokesman Ahmed Shide said on Wednesday that the reopening of two critical roads leading to the ports of Assab in Eritrea’s south and Massawa in the north would benefit the whole region.

“The unfolding developments will not only benefit our peoples, but the entire Horn of Africa region will be a part of these developments,” Shide was quoted as saying in an interview published on the Eritrean information ministry’s website.

Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed’s chief of staff wrote on Twitter that Ethiopian and Eritrean passport holders would be able to travel to the other country and obtain visas on arrival.

The changes are sweeping away years of hostility and raising hopes in both countries for a lucrative peace dividend.

Access to the ports of Assab and Massawa could greatly help Ethiopia’s push to boost their exports and increase hard currency earnings, analysts say.

Ethiopia And Eritrea Declare End Of War

The leaders of Ethiopia and Eritrea signed a “Joint declaration of peace and friendship” on Monday 9 July, a day after a historic summit marked a start to normalisation of ties between the former foes.

“The state of war between Ethiopia and Eritrea has come to an end,” the leaders said in a joint declaration. “A new era of peace and friendship has been opened.”

The Agreement, which specifies five pillars, was signed this morning at State House by President Isaias Afwerki and Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed.

The Joint Declaration states, inter alia, that:

i) The State of war that existed between the two countries has come to an end. A new era of peace and friendship has been ushered;

ii) Both countries will work to promote close cooperation in political, economic, social, cultural and security areas.

iii) Transport, trade and telecommunication ties will be resumed; diplomatic ties and activities renewed;

iv) The border decision will be implemented;

v) Both countries will work together to guarantee regional peace, development and cooperation

“This move opens prospects for real, regional economic integration. Get the economic underpinnings of the region right and you get stability,” said Alex Rondos, the European Union’s special representative for the Horn of Africa.

“There are enormous potential complementarities between the two countries if the recent political advances are consolidated,” said Andrew Mold, who heads the East Africa office of the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa.

Ethiopian airlines to resume flights to Asmara next week

Ethiopian Airlines (Ethiopian), Africa’s largest airline, will resume flights to Eritrean capital Asmara next week.

This was announced yesterday by the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Ethiopia, Dr Workneh Gebeyhu, following the conclusion of a two-day visit by an Ethiopian delegation led by Prime Minister Dr Abiy Ahmed to Eritrea.

Ethiopia PM asks diaspora to save ‘a dollar a day’ to support development projects

While defending the 346.9 billion Ethiopian birr ($12.71 billion) budget for 2018/19 on Friday 6 July, PM Abiy Ahmed made a passionate appeal to the diaspora community to support the ongoing reforms in the country by establishing a ‘Diaspora Trust Fund’ that can reduce aid dependency and facilitate investment in critical sectors such as education and health.

‘‘Diaspora, here is a call to you! A dollar a day to help children get an education, our brothers and sisters, fathers and mothers get health service, and above all, consider this as ‘paying back’ to your people who gave you a future while they had no one.’‘

HE PM Abiy Ahmed called for the establishment of  a Diaspora Trust Fund that could be managed independently and would not only boosts savings and investments but could also be used to support national collective initiatives.

Ethiopia’s global diaspora is estimated to be two-million strong, with the highest numbers in the US, totalling anything from 250,000 up to about one million.

The government also recently demonstrated its commitment to the diaspora community when the cabinet approved the Amnesty Law that grants amnesty for individuals and groups, either under investigation or convicted on treason, crimes against the constitutional order and armed struggle.

Eritrea and Ethiopia set to re-establish diplomatic and trade ties

After long years of hostility, Ethiopia and Eritrea have agreed to restore relations following a landmark meeting between the two countries’ leaders in Asmara. It was the first time in almost 20 years the leaders from the two East African neighbours have met.

In addition, their airlines will start operating; the ports will be accessible, people will be able to move between the two countries and embassies will be opened in their respective capitals.

“If there is peace between Ethiopian and Eritrean people, the Horn of Africa region will be a region of peace and development. Our people who live scattered as refugees in humiliation will come back with dignity. Our citizens will not be sold and exchanged like commodities,“Ethiopian Prime Minister, Dr Abiy Ahmed said.

Direct international telephone connection was also restored on Sunday between Ethiopia and Eritrea for the first time after two decades.

PM Abiy also said that Ethiopia would soon begin using the port of neighbouring Eritrea.

The re-establishment of diplomatic and trade ties after years of separation could mean significant benefits for both nations, and the wider Horn of Africa region, plagued by conflict and poverty.

Ethiopia’s PM Abiy Ahmed in Eritrea for landmark visit

With hugs and cheers, the leaders of Ethiopia and Eritrea have met for the first time in more than 20 years amid a recent thawing in relations between the former East African rivals.

In a landmark visit, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed landed in the Eritrean capital, Asmara, on Sunday 8 July, for a bilateral summit aimed at repairing relations between the two countries. Eritrean President Isaias Afwerki warmly greeted Abiy at the airport.

This week’s summit aims to “further deepen efforts to bring about lasting peace,” said Abiy’s chief of staff, Fitsum Arega. “Our two nations share a history and bond like no other,” he said on Twitter. “We can now overcome two decades of mistrust and move in a new direction.”

Upon arrival at Asmara, the Ethiopian Prime Minister was welcomed by Eritrean President Isaias Afeworki and other senior Eritrean government officials.

Video footage from the Ethiopian state television showed crowds dancing and singing for the two leaders at the Asmara International Airport.

In advance of Abiy’s arrival, Ethiopian Information Minister Meskel said the visit “heralds a new era of peace and cooperation”.

Following a private meeting between President Isaias Afwerki and PM Abiy Ahmed, Ethiopia and Eritrea have agreed to restore diplomatic relations. The two leaders also attended a dinner and announced new measures.

Prime Minister Dr Abiy on the occasion said: “We have agreed to reopen embassies in our respective countries, allow our people to visit each other’s cities and allow our airlines and ports to operate freely.”

Moreover, the two countries have also agreed to restore a direct international telephone connection between them.

Ethiopian Premier further said the two leaders have “agreed to bring down the wall between us. Now there is no border between Ethiopia and Eritrea. That borderline has gone today with the display of a true love … love is greater than modern weapons like tanks and missiles.”

The Eritrean leader also expressed his delight about the new era of friendly relations between the two countries.

“The Eritrean people have today got the chance to express their true love and emotion for Ethiopians,” said Isaias.

“We can imagine that the decisions the prime minister of Ethiopia took were not a simple one. But we can assure you we will face the future together. We will work as one,” he added.

Prime Minister Abiy to travel to the US this month to meet with the diaspora

Prime Minister Dr Abiy Ahmed will travel to the United States at the end of this month. The objective of his trip is to hold face-to-face meetings with Ethiopian Diaspora in the US.

It also aims at boosting the involvement of all Ethiopian Diaspora living in the US in the ongoing reforms, development, and democratisation in their country of birth.

His trip will be held under the theme “demolishing the wall, let‘s build the bridge.”

The Premier will meet Ethiopians in Washington, DC on July 28 and those living in Los Angeles on July 29, 2018.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs is inviting all Ethiopians to participate in the meeting, regardless of their political ideology, religion, and ethnic background.

Ambassador Teshome briefs EU Africa experts on the ongoing reforms in Ethiopia

On Wednesday 4 July 2018, Ambassador Teshome Toga met with the 28 members of the Africa Working Party (COAFR) to brief them about the rapid changes taking place in Ethiopia and say goodbye to them, as he will be leaving Brussels this week.

He started his address by explaining that since Prime minister Dr Abiy Ahmed was elected Chairman of the EPRDF, significant changes have taken place at the political, economic and diplomatic levels in Ethiopia.

Politically, PM Abiy Ahmed has first and foremost been engaging with the public. To do so, he has held town hall meetings in eight of Ethiopia’s nine regions so far to listen to the people’s grievances. He also reshuffled the Cabinet, pardoned thousands of prisoners, engaged in a dialogue with opposition parties and lifted the State of emergency. All this brought back peace and stability to the country.

Another issue is that Ethiopia’s growing economy has become increasingly complex. There is, therefore, a need for increased investments from the private sector and foreign currency. Last month, the government took the bold decision to privatise some of Ethiopia’s critical State-owned enterprises such as Ethio-Telecom and Ethiopian Airlines partially. The main objective is to promote exportations and the transformation of the economy and, ultimately, with job creation as the ultimate objective.

On the diplomatic plan, PM Abiy has been touring neighbouring countries as well as Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the Emirates Arab United to reinforce existing links and promote regional integration. However, two recent events could drastically change the course of the Horn of Africa region. Salva Kiir and Riek Machar came together for the first time in two years, paving the way to a ceasefire in South Sudan. A true regional revolution is also on the road since Eritrea accepted Ethiopia’s olive branch, which resulted and the first visit of an Eritrean delegation to Ethiopia in 20 years.

All this took place over a very brief period – less than 100 days. Ambassador’s realistically noted that although Ethiopia’s problems are not yet over, the people are supportive and listening. The priority for the government should be to deliver on its commitment.

Ambassador Teshome concluded his address by saying that he hoped that the EU would continue to encourage the reforms in Ethiopia in several ways, including to create jobs on the ground, supporting Ethiopia’s peace and security efforts and collaborating on global issues such as climate change or anti-terrorism efforts.

Ms Michelle LABEEU, Deputy Head of Unit Easter Africa and Horn of Africa at DG Devco, then informed the audience about the sectoral dialogue on social and economic development, investment, trade and climate change that took place in Addis of 2 and 3 July 2018.

The EU and Ethiopia appreciated the extremely constructive discussions. Ethiopia demonstrated a firm commitment for liberalisation, opening and regional integration. Both sides have agreed to continue to have this kind of discussion yearly. Besides, progress has also been made to organise an EU-Ethiopia business forum in Brussels.

Several representatives from the EU Member States appreciated Ambassador Teshome’s efforts while he was in Brussels and welcomed the scope and depth of the current reforms. Most of the audience asked questions about the next steps Ethiopia was going to take in its internal discussions as well as in its relations with Egypt and Eritrea. France’s Representative compared the recent developments between Ethiopia and Eritrea to the fall of the Berlin wall in 1989.

Ambassador Teshome replied that while he understands Egypt’s concerns, Cairo should also respect Ethiopia’s rights on the river. Ethiopia will only use the Grand Renaissance dam to produce electricity and will not take water from Egypt. He added that while the GERD is the pillar of the relationship between Ethiopia and Egypt, there is also a need to extend it to other important areas such investment and trade.

On the regional side, he confirmed that Eritrea would probably integrate IGAD soon and that a meeting between Ethiopia and Eritrea leaders is on the works. He added that given the current positive and constructive spirit, the security should improve significantly on the Horn of Africa.

Politically, the next steps in Ethiopia will be to continue to discuss with the recently returned opposition parties and obtain consensus on several critical issues for the country, such as the current federal arrangement. However, it noted that this would not be a “top-down” approach, as the process will be open and transparent.

Finally, Ambassador Teshome concluded by hoping that the EU would work with Ethiopia on identifying real challenges on the ground. The EU is a model of democratisation and regional integration, and Ethiopia is willing to learn from its best practices.

DP World considering logistics facility in Ethiopia

DP World is planning to set up a logistics facility in Ethiopia to transport goods from a port it is developing in neighbouring Somaliland.

The Nasdaq-listed company’s logistics complex in the east African country would transport goods to various landlocked states on the continent, said Sultan bin Sulayem, chairman of DP World, according to UAE news agency Wam.

The company, one of the world’s top five largest port operators, signed an agreement with the Somaliland government in 2016 to invest $442 million (Dh1.62 billion) in the Port of Berbera on Africa’s east coast and manage it in a 30-year concession. In March, Ethiopia became a 19 per cent shareholder in the Port of Berbera, with DP World controlling 51 per cent stake in the project and Somaliland holding the remaining 30 per cent.

DP World’s planned facility in Ethiopia would strengthen its position in Africa, Mr bin Sulayem said.

“Business groups in Dubai can always benefit from DP World’s presence in different countries including Rwanda and Egypt where re-exporting opportunities are abundant,” he remarked during an open dialogue with trade and business groups in Dubai.

The company is expected to post a 17 per cent growth in second-quarter profit compared to the same period a year ago, Egyptian investment bank EFG Hermes said in a report on regional equities last week.

DP World’s terminals in Europe, Middle East and Africa, which also includes the home port of Jebel Ali in Dubai, recorded growth in the first quarter of 2018, up 9.8 per cent the same quarter last year.